Beware of vendors bearing SOA gifts

The healthcare sector manages an estimated 90 billing healthcare transactions globally; unfortunately, more than 90 percent are happening via phone, fax, or postal mail.

In order for healthcare organizations to better manage today’s information technology requirements, they require modern tools that are designed to work with legacy infrastructures in a service oriented approach/architecture (SOA) where middleware is able to get information to and from multiple systems and applications that have likely been around for decades.

SOA is not a tool, it’s not a library, and it’s definitely not something you can buy and toss into your stack. If you’d like to get an executive summary of SOA, take a look at my Enabling the Service Oriented Enterprise – Overcoming the hype, misconceptions, and pitfalls of SOA PowerPoint presentation.

Even though SOA makes a good deal of sense in the healthcare IT industry, be careful of the hype and existing vendors simply “SOA enabling” their existing software suite. It’s not going to be easy to convert closed legacy healthcare systems into open service oriented applications and databases. Cerner or IDX won’t be able to become “service oriented” by slapping on a label. Epic and Meditech can’t become service oriented given that they couldn’t even make the move to object oriented quickly. Eclipsys and Seimans can’t just put in a messaging system and tell you that they’re now service enabled because they can pass messages between systems.

Before your existing vendors come to you with their SOA message, have them explain to you what they think about SOA, why they think you should care, and why systems that they’ve had around for years are now, suddenly, service oriented. Almost all complex healthcare IT are integration oriented (by utilizing standards such as HL7) but won’t be easily converted to a service oriented quickly or without major changes.

Newsletter Sign Up

One thought on “Beware of vendors bearing SOA gifts

  1. Hi,

    I am currently a student of MBS “Information Systems for Business Performance” at University College Cork, Ireland. As a final part of the programme I have to carry out an industry-based project. Therefore, I am writing on the behalf of my group regarding our thesis project. We are investigating how SOA can influence the IT capability of a firm and to what extend this strategy can become a major initiative for changing the underlined business approach of an organization.
    We came across your blog and we are wondering if you could help us by filling out a survey. We would really appreciate if you could forward our survey to friends (through your blog) and colleges who you think can contribute positively to this survey.

    The survey is in two parts and will take no longer than 5-10 minutes. It is located at:

    Part 1

    Part 2

    We would also appreciate any additional comments you may have or additional assistance you would like to provide.

    If you have any questions or comments, please contact me at 353 – 879717181 or
    I am hoping for your kind consideration and participation.
    Many Thanks,
    Magdalena Lisowska

Add Comment